How to choose an assisted living facility — without getting cold-called by ten of them.
Vetting guideBy Intake Senior10 min read
The senior care industry has earned its reputation. Fill out one form online and you’ll get phone calls from numbers you don’t recognize for the next two weeks. Walk into a community without research and you’ll be quoted a base rate that’s $1,800 a month below what you’ll actually pay. This is a step-by-step guide to vetting communities the way an industry insider does — whether you hire an advisor or do it yourself.
Run a state inspection check first.
Before you tour anything, look up the community’s last three years of inspections. This narrows your list faster than any other single move.
- Maryland — Search for “Maryland Office of Health Care Quality assisted living” (OHCQ, under MDH). Their database has inspection reports for licensed communities.
- Virginia — Search for “Virginia Department of Social Services assisted living inspections”. VDSS licenses and inspects assisted living. The Department of Health handles nursing homes.
- Nursing homes (national) — Use medicare.gov/care-compare — CMS’s star ratings, staffing data, and recent deficiency citations.
Focus on health and safety violations and repeated violations that weren’t addressed. Don’t panic about a single record-keeping citation. Ignore communities with consistent serious violations across multiple years.
Read reviews like a forensic auditor.
People who are happy with a community don’t leave reviews. People who are furious do — but so do people processing guilt about placing a parent. Don’t read individual stories. Read for patterns.
- Google & Yelp — Sort by lowest first. Look for the same complaint cited five+ times. One person calling a community “the worst place on earth” tells you nothing. Five people independently mentioning “medications missed” or “call lights ignored at night” tells you everything.
- Glassdoor — Look up the community as an employer. Recurring complaints from staff about understaffing, mandatory overtime, or mistreatment are red flags — that becomes resident experience within months.
- LinkedIn — Search the community by name. Look at current and past employees. High turnover at the executive director, director of nursing, or director of care positions in the last 24 months is a major signal.
Tour with intention, not enthusiasm.
The formal tour is curated — they show you the activity room during programming, the dining hall before the cleanup, the model unit. The real tour is the 30 minutes you spend in the lobby or main hallway when no one’s watching you.
- Arrive 15 minutes early and sit in the lobby. Note: are residents talking to each other or sitting alone? Are staff using residents’ first names?
- Walk past a hallway. Does it smell? A faint smell of disinfectant is fine. The smell of urine is not.
- On a second visit, ask to eat lunch. The food is the daily experience for your loved one — try it.
- Watch how staff respond when a call light goes off. Are they hurrying or strolling?
- Ask to see the activity calendar. Anything more than bingo and a Wednesday sing-along is a good sign.
- Ask: “How do you handle a resident who’s lonely on a Sunday afternoon?” The answer reveals the culture.
Ask for the ALL-IN cost — never the base rate.
Most assisted living is priced à la carte. The brochure rate is the Level 1 base rate. Bathing assistance, medication management, escorts to the dining room, transportation to doctor appointments — most of these are billed separately. By month six, the bill is often $1,500–2,500 above the base.
Use this script
“Can you give me the all-in monthly cost if my [mother / father] needs help with bathing, dressing, medication management, transportation to doctor appointments, and incontinence care? I want a number that includes a likely Level 2 or Level 3 assessment, not just the base rate.”
Memory care is usually different — most memory care rates are flat (all services included). The exception is incontinence supplies, which are often billed separately.
Look at staff tenure, not the lobby.
The fanciest lobby with the highest staff turnover is worse than the dated community where the head caregiver has been there for fifteen years. Staff tenure is the single most predictive measure of resident experience.
- Ask the executive director: “How long have you been here? How long has your director of care been here? What’s the average tenure of your care staff?”
- Religious and non-profit communities tend to have higher tenure on average. They’re not always cheaper or prettier, but their employees usually stay longer and care more.
- If the executive director can’t answer the tenure question without checking, that’s an answer.
Pick a community with memory care on-site if there’s any chance you'll need it.
About a third of assisted living residents eventually move to memory care. If that’s a possibility — early dementia, vascular cognitive issues, family history — pick a community where the memory care unit is on the same campus, run by the same operator. The transition is dramatically smoother. One move instead of two. Same staff who already know your loved one. Same dining room.
Cameras are okay — and useful — in private rooms.
Most communities allow a Wyze or Nest-type camera in a private apartment. Shared rooms are off-limits for privacy reasons. Set the camera in the living area, not the bathroom or bedroom. Use it to confirm your loved one made it to lunch, not to micromanage the staff. If you see a fall, you can call the front desk faster than the call light reaches a caregiver.
If you hire an advisor, ask three questions first.
Most senior care advisors take a referral fee from the community when a family moves in. That fee model isn’t inherently scammy — it’s how the industry works — but the advisor’s incentives and disclosure are. Before you hire any advisor (including us), ask:
- “How are you compensated? Do you take a referral fee from the community? Is your fee tied to placement volume?”
- “Will my contact information be shared with more than one community before I’ve chosen one?”
- “Have you ever told a family the right answer was to stay home or use in-home care, even when that earned you nothing?”
An honest advisor answers all three plainly. A scammy one deflects.
Use your county long-term care ombudsman.
Every state and most counties have a long-term care ombudsman office that advocates for residents and investigates complaints. Free. Independent. They can’t recommend a community, but they can tell you which ones have had complaints recently. In Maryland, search “Maryland Department of Aging long-term care ombudsman.” In Virginia, search “Virginia long-term care ombudsman.”
Ask in your local Facebook group.
Local neighborhood Facebook groups are an underrated source. Ask: “Looking for assisted living recommendations in [your area]. We’re especially interested in places with strong staff tenure and good memory care.” The recommendations you get from people who’ve actually walked the halls are worth more than aggregated review scores.
FAQ
Is it normal for a senior care advisor to take a referral fee from communities?
Yes — most advisor services in this country are paid by the community when a family moves in. The referral fee itself isn't the issue. The issue is whether the advisor discloses it up front and whether their compensation is tied to placement volume in a way that creates an incentive to steer you to the wrong community. Ask any advisor: how are you paid, do you take placements you wouldn't recommend personally, and would you tell me to stay home or use in-home care if that were the right answer? The honest ones answer all three plainly.
Why am I getting non-stop calls after filling out an online form?
Most lead-generation senior care sites sell each lead to multiple communities simultaneously — sometimes ten or more. Each community then assigns a sales rep to call you. The sales reps are compensated on tours and move-ins, so they call hard. If you've been hit by this, ask whoever you give your number to next: 'Will my information be shared with more than one community before I've chosen one?' If the answer is anything but no, walk away.
How do I check if a facility has had inspection violations?
In Maryland, the Office of Health Care Quality (OHCQ) publishes assisted living and nursing home inspection results. In Virginia, the Department of Social Services (DSS) publishes assisted living inspections, and the Department of Health publishes nursing home inspections. For nursing homes nationally, CMS Care Compare (medicare.gov/care-compare) shows star ratings, staffing data, and recent deficiencies. Look at the last three years of inspections, focus on health-related and repeated violations, and treat record-keeping violations as low priority.
What's the single most useful question to ask on a tour?
"What would my all-in monthly cost be if my mother needs help with bathing, dressing, medication management, and transportation to doctor appointments?" The brochure rate is the Level 1 base rate. The all-in number is what you'll actually pay once a level-of-care assessment puts your loved one at Level 2 or Level 3 — which most residents reach within twelve months. Always ask for the all-in number.
What should I look for during a tour?
Are residents clean and dressed? Are they talking to each other or sitting alone in a hallway? Is the staff smiling and using residents' first names? Does the place smell? Try the food. Sit in the main area for 15-45 minutes before or after the formal tour and just watch. The formal tour shows you the community at its best; the unwatched 30 minutes shows you the community at its average.
Are religious or non-profit facilities better?
On average, yes — though there are excellent for-profit communities too. Religious and non-profit facilities tend to invest more in staff retention, which translates to caregivers who know your loved one's name, history, and routines. Staff tenure is the single most predictive measure of resident experience. When you tour, ask: "How long has your director of care been here? What's the average tenure of your care staff?"
Want a second pair of eyes on this?
The above is the DIY version. If you’d rather have someone who’s already toured the communities run this with you — including the inspection checks, the all-in cost negotiation, and the funding paths — that’s what we do. Free to families. We never share your phone with multiple communities at once. Five questions and we’ll call you back within 48 hours.
Keep reading
More guides for the questions families ask.
How do I know when it's time?
Signs your parent is ready, the six ADLs, the three AL tiers.
What does senior care actually cost?
Real numbers, no info gate, by region and setting.
What if the hospital says "48 hours"?
Skilled rehab vs. home with services vs. AL — the Medicare appeal.
What if there's no money for care?
Medicaid, A&A, look-back, group homes, elder-law.
Five questions, then a real human.
No charge to families. No spam. No offshore intake teams.
Start the intake